Every year, excellent loggers and athletes are revealed at the Buckley Log Show. They receive trophies for Most Effort, Sportsmanship, Best Load of Logs, Crew Relay and first, second and third place in the events. One outstanding logger gets a trophy for being the All-Around Logger. Contestants compete for All-Around Logger by receiving points in each of the events they place in. The contestant with the most points after the two days are up is named All-Around Logger. These are the All-Around Loggers to date:
Carl Kaszycki
1976, 1977
Bill Clinkingbeard
1978
Elmer Timmons
1979, 1980, 1982, 1983
Andy Cunningham
1981
Randy Gabrielson
1984, 1985
Pat Hurley
1986
Dave Flanders
1987, 1988, 1989, 1993,
1994, 1995 (co-winner),
1996, 1997
Jeff Fetter
1990, 1991 (co-winner)
Bud Hanson
1991 (co-winner), 1992
Sonny Frick
1995 (co-winner), 2005
Tim Gray
1998, 1999, 2000,
2001, 2002, 2004
Jeff Carlson
2003, 2006
2007 (co-winner), 2008
Tyson Hanson
2007 (co-winner)